Store Credit vs Discount Calculator
Store credit or a Black Friday discount? Enter your own numbers and see which offer leaves more profit per customer.
Reading
How the calculation works
With a discount, every Black Friday customer buys at the lower price, so profit per customer is order value times your margin after the discount. With credit, the first order sells at full price. Then the share of customers who come back in January spend the credit, and each of those orders earns its normal margin minus the credit.
- Take a £60 first order at a 65% margin. At 20% off, profit is £60 times 45%, which is £27.00.
- At full price the first order makes £39.00. Give £10 of January credit, and if 30% of customers come back with a £50 order, each of those makes £32.50 minus £10, so £22.50. Across all customers that's 30% of £22.50, or £6.75.
- Credit makes £45.75 per customer against £27.00 for the discount.
Both figures are before ad spend. The return rate is your guess, so try a low one too. Nothing you type leaves this page. The sums run in your browser.
How to run a credit offer
- Keep full price all week. The credit is the offer, for example "Spend £X, get £Y to spend in January."
- The credit can't be used on the same order. Put it in their account, or send a single-use code after delivery.
- Say the dates plainly, for example valid 1 to 31 January. Check your gift card and consumer law terms before launch.
- Email a reminder on 2 January and again a week before the credit runs out.
What to do next
- Read how Black Friday offers change your margin in our Black Friday discount guide.
- Work out the ROAS you need on the sale with the break-even ROAS calculator.
- Plan the week's budget with the Black Friday spend plan.
FAQ
Is store credit better than a discount on Black Friday?
It can leave more profit per customer, because the first order sells at full price and the credit only costs you margin on the orders where it gets spent. A discount wins when it would bring in many more orders than credit, or when the credit is bigger than your margin on the second order. Put your own numbers in the calculator to see which one wins for you.
Why does Apple give gift cards instead of Black Friday discounts?
Apple has offered gift cards with purchases in place of price cuts on Black Friday since 2013, and the card can't be spent on the same purchase. In 2025 the 15-inch MacBook Air came with a $200 gift card. The product keeps its full price and the card gives the customer a reason to come back for a second order.
How much does store credit cost?
Only the margin you give up on the order where it's spent, and only for the customers who come back to spend it. At a 70% margin, $66 of credit costs about the same as $20 off. People don't always value a gift card as highly as cash, so test the size of the credit.
What return rate should I enter?
Use last year's repeat rate from your Black Friday customers if you have it. If you don't, enter a low guess and see whether credit still wins. The result moves a lot with this number.
Does a bigger discount sell more?
It might, and the calculator compares profit per customer, not the number of customers. If you think 20% off would sell 30% more orders, multiply the discount result by 1.3 before you compare.
Want a second pair of eyes on the account?
Book a call with the MHI team. We make ads and buy Meta media for DTC brands.